I ordered a pack of Oil-Resistant Soft Buna-N O-Rings, 3/32 Fractional Width, Dash Number 132. Part number 2418T151.
These have an ID of 1.737" and a thickness of 0.103". Less than $10 for a pack of 20, but shipping is another $8!
These seemed to fit ok, but might be a little loose. Probably should have gone down one size for a stretch-tight fit.